All summer, your gutters have nothing to do. Then the first big storm rolls in off the Pacific, and in one night you find out what they can and can’t handle.
That makes right now the best time to look. Here are eight signs worth checking, what each means, and what to do. Most you can see from the ground.
1. Overflow During Rain
What it means: Water spilling over the front edge usually means a clog, either in the gutter or the downspout. If the gutters are clean and still overflow, they may be undersized for the roof, pitched wrong, or short on downspouts.
What to do: Start with a cleaning and a downspout flush. If clean gutters still overflow, the fix is usually adjusting the pitch or adding a downspout.
2. Water Running Behind the Gutter
What it means: Water dripping between the gutter and the house means it’s getting past the back edge, often from a gutter that’s pulled away or missing flashing at the roof edge.
What to do: Usually a repair: rehanging the gutter or adding flashing. Don’t wait on it. That water goes straight into the fascia or rafter tails.
3. Sagging Gutters or Gutters Pulling Away From the House
What it means: Sagging gutters and gutters pulling away from the house usually point to loose or failed hangers, or fasteners that have lost their grip in the wood. A gutter full of wet debris is heavy, and the first storm often finishes the job.
What to do: If the wood behind it is solid, whether that’s a fascia board or the rafter tails on homes without fascia, rehanging with new hangers is a routine repair. If the wood is soft, it needs to be fixed first, or the new hangers won’t hold either.
4. Leaking Seams and Corners
What it means: Leaking gutter seams are a common post-storm find. On sectional gutters, every joint is sealed, and sealant breaks down over time.
What to do: A few leaking seams or corners can be resealed. Leaks at joint after joint often mean the system is near the end. Seamless gutters are formed on site from a single coil, so each run is one continuous piece. The only joints are at the corners, which means far fewer places to leak.
5. Peeling Paint or Rot on the Fascia or Rafter Tails
What it means: Peeling paint, dark stains or soft spots on the fascia board, or on the rafter tails if your gutters attach directly to them, mean water has been getting behind the gutter for a while, often longer than one season.
What to do: Small areas can often be repaired. Widespread rot means the gutter has to come down so the wood can be repaired, and that’s a good moment to ask whether the same gutter should go back up.
6. Rust, Cracks or Holes
What it means: Rust spots on steel gutters and cracks or splits in older gutters are signs the material itself is breaking down. One small hole is a repair. Rust in several places means more is coming.
What to do: Isolated damage can be patched or a short section replaced. Rust or cracking along the length of a run is a replacement sign, since patching becomes a cycle.
7. Pooling at the Foundation
What it means: Puddles along the house usually trace back to a downspout that dumps too close to the wall, a loose extension or a clogged underground drain.
What to do: Walk the house during a rain and watch where the water goes. Most of the time the fix is at the downspout, not the gutter.
8. A System That Is Simply Old
What it means: Sometimes nothing dramatic is wrong. The gutters are just old, patched and rehung more than once, and every storm turns up something new.
What to do: If you’re fixing something every season, repairs are no longer the better option, and a new system is worth a look.
Gutter Repair vs Replacement: How to Tell
A repair usually makes sense when:
- The problem is in one spot: a seam, a corner, a sagging section
- The gutters are the right size and the metal is sound
- The fascia or rafter tails behind them are solid
Replacement is worth considering when:
- Leaks, rust or sagging show up in several places
- The fascia or rafter tails need repair along a whole run
- The gutters are too small to handle the roof, even when clean
- You’re repairing the same system every year
We’ll tell you which one you’re looking at. If a gutter repair is all you need, that’s what we’ll recommend. If it’s time for new gutters, we’ll show you why, in writing, and you can decide from there.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Are the Signs Your Gutters Need to Be Replaced?
The strongest signs are problems in several places at once: leaks at multiple seams, rust or cracks along a run, widespread rot in the fascia or rafter tails, gutters too small for the roof, or a system that needs repairs every season. One problem in one spot is usually a repair.
Can Sagging Gutters Be Repaired?
Usually, yes. Sagging is most often caused by loose or failed hangers, and rehanging the gutter with new hangers fixes it. If the fascia or rafter tails behind the gutter are rotted, that wood has to be repaired first so the hangers have solid wood to hold.
Why Are My Gutter Seams Leaking?
On sectional gutters, each joint is sealed, and that sealant breaks down with age and weather. Corners are the most common spot on any system. A few leaks can be resealed. Seamless gutters, formed on site in one piece per run, only have joints at the corners.
Should I Repair or Replace My Gutters After a Storm?
It depends on what the storm revealed. If the damage is limited to one section and the rest of the system is sound, repair it. If the storm turned up problems all around the house, replacement may be the better long-term choice. An inspection will tell you which.
Book a free gutter inspection while the storm damage is fresh. Get a free quote or call (650) 600-0598.
